Live, Measuring and Verified: What Each Status Means
Updated
From Written to Proven#
| Status | What it means | Where you see it |
|---|---|---|
| Applied | Your site accepted the change | Live feed; the card moves to Measuring |
| Checked on your site | SEOmatic opened your live page and saw the change. This is the proof it is live | Live on your site list, with Live since and See it live |
| Done, measuring the impact | Waiting for the measuring window to end | Measuring column, with the date the verdict is due |
| Confirmed: it worked | A verified win | The card, the Live feed (It worked), and your weekly report |
| Finished, no measurable effect | The change shipped, but any gain was too small to tell apart from normal ups and downs | The card |
| Finished, results unclear | Not enough data to judge, or the change was never confirmed on your site | The card |
| Too early to tell, moving the right way | The page is gaining, but not yet by enough to prove it | The card and your weekly report |
| Went backwards, rolled back | Results got clearly worse and your agent put the page back | The card and the Live on your site column |
| Went backwards, waiting for you to undo it | Results got worse, but not clearly enough to undo it on its own. Your change is still live | The card and Needs you |
Measuring does not prove a change is live
The Measuring column's subtitle says live on your site, but a card arrives there as soon as your site accepts the change. Only the Live on your site list, with Checked on your site, proves it is on the page. If a change never appears there, see my site still shows the old version.
Open a card to see its steps. After the change is live, the Seen by Google step says when Google crawled the page again, whether it is indexed, whether Google shows your title or rewrote it, and whether Google picked another page as the main one. Until Google comes back, it says Waiting for Google to crawl the page again.
How a Win Is Judged#
Your agents compare the page's clicks after the change with its clicks before, then take away how much your whole site moved over the same days. That way a good month for your site, or a slow season, is not counted as the fix's doing.
- A win needs all three: more than 10% better than the rest of your site, at least 5 extra clicks, and a gain clearly larger than normal day-to-day noise.
- Title, description and social preview changes can also win on click rate: at least 15% more of the people who see your result click it, with 50 or more impressions, at the same ranking, and at least 5 extra clicks. The verdict then says Won on click-through rate.
- Page-one pushes and internal links can also win on ranking: the page moves up at least 1.5 places more than your site does, with 30 or more impressions. The verdict says Won on ranking. This does not count during a week when Google's rankings move across many sites.
- It must beat similar pages. Besides the rest of your site, SEOmatic compares the page with similar pages your agents did not touch over the same days. If those pages gained as much, it is not a win.
- Wins wait during Google updates. When Google's rankings move across many sites, both wins and losses wait one more week before they are judged.
- Bulk campaigns need more extra clicks the more pages they cover.
- The change must be on your site. If SEOmatic never confirmed it, the result is not counted as a win.
Open a finished card and read How we know. It shows the numbers, for example how much the page moved and how much the rest of your site moved.
Pages with Very Little Traffic#
A page with almost no clicks cannot prove anything on its own. So when your agents plan the same kind of change on several quiet pages in a month, half of them, picked at random, go live as soon as they are approved and the other half wait about a month (4 to 8 weeks). The pages that wait are the comparison. The result is then read for the group, for example how much the pages changed first gained against the pages held back. Every page still gets its change. Trial accounts are never held back this way.
When Results Get Worse#
A change counts as worse when it was live, the page lost more than 15% compared with the rest of your site, at least 5 clicks were lost, and the drop is beyond normal noise. Your agent only undoes it on its own when the harm is clear: a drop about three times larger than normal noise and at least 20 clicks lost (more for a change across many pages).
| Kind of change | What happens | Card line |
|---|---|---|
| Small fix marked Undo in one click, clear harm | The agent puts the page back on its own. During a week when Google's rankings move across many sites, it asks you instead | Results got worse, so the agent put this page back as it was. |
| Small fix marked Undo in one click, smaller drop | Nothing is undone, because drops this size also happen on pages nobody touched. It waits in Needs you | ...so we left your change live. Review it and roll back if you want. |
| Small fix whose automatic undo failed | You get an email titled Action needed. Nothing else touches the page until you decide | Results got worse and the agent could not undo it automatically - worth a look. |
| Bigger change | Nothing is undone. It waits in Needs you as Regressed, needs a rollback | Results got worse. This one needs you to undo it |
The status says what really happened: Went backwards, rolled back only when the page was put back, otherwise Went backwards, waiting for you to undo it, Went backwards, your agent is undoing it or Went backwards, could not be undone automatically. To undo it yourself, click Undo in the Live on your site list or the undo arrow in the Live feed. You can also keep the change if you disagree with the measurement. See why a change was rolled back.
Requests to Google#
A Help Google find the page task changes nothing on your page. After 7 days the card shows what Google's own check says about the page, for example whether it is now indexed. It counts as a win only when the page was not indexed before, is indexed now, and similar pages nobody touched were not indexed in the same weeks. If many of them were, Google may well have indexed it on its own, and the card says so.
Live Feed Labels#
| Label | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Suggested | Proposed, waiting for a decision |
| Working | Running now |
| Applied | Written to your site |
| For your review | Prepared and held for you |
| Measuring | Waiting for the verdict |
| It worked | A verified win |
| Rolled back | A setback, such as a change that was undone |
| Checkpoint | A decision was recorded, for example an approval |
- Why does a finished card say "Measured, but our checker could never confirm this change on your live page"?
- Your site accepted the change, but SEOmatic never saw it on the page, often because your site blocks automated visitors or a cache served an old copy. It is measured, but never counted as a win. Open the page yourself to check.
- Does "no measurable effect" mean I should undo the change?
- Not necessarily. It means the gain, if any, was too small to prove. The change did no measurable harm. Keep it unless you prefer the old version.
Was This Article Helpful?
Still need help?Email contact@seomatic.ai with your site address and a screenshot. A person replies, usually within one business day.


